Vol 3 Issue 3

Back to Table of Contents


MIKE THODOROFF describes the competitive formula for a place in the engineering world

Getting hired as an engineer back in the heyday of America's motor vehicle industry was, for the most part, ingenuous. Then Honda was known only for producing 50 cc motorcycles, Toyota was virtually an unknown and Hyundai sounded like something you shouted as you tried to karate-chop your way through some pine boards. A twoyear degree from a trade or technical college was enough to get your foot in the door of any manufacturer or supplier. Of course, you had to walk in that door wearing a short-sleeved white shirt and narrow black tie with the omnipresent pocket protector chock-full of mechanical pencils and – most impressive of all – a slide rule.

My, how times have changed. Today there are no certain criteria for landing an engineering position, but there are some basic prerequisites; a bachelor's degree, proven demonstration of time management skills and documented exposure to project management are beginnings. But, psssst…here's an industry trade secret. Attendance at a college or university engineering school and getting involved in its Formula SAE (fSAE) program will enhance the chances for subsequently getting hired into a real-world engineering position.

Formula SAE challenges teams of students to conceive, design, and fabricate small open-wheel formula-style spec racing cars and then compete against the cars of teams from other schools. A team typically spends up to twelve months going through design iterations, then the construction, testing and competition prepping of their car. FSAE consists of multiple phases of controlled contests during which team members gain experience as they demonstrate their capabilities, and those of their vehicles, against teams and cars that come from around the world.

Currently there are eight fSAE competitions held annually (refer to sidebar for 2007 dates and locations). As an example, last year's Michigan fSAE event had 140 teams from eleven different countries, including the US and Canada, vying with one another. Events are always “over subscribed” with online registrations that often close within minutes of opening because the capacity has been meet. Formula SAE began in 1981, evolving from a program called Mini-Indy that had itself begun as a collaboration between SAE and the University of Houston, held on campus in Texas. Rules for Mini-Indy specified 5 hp Briggs and Stratton engines on basic go-kart frames. Over the years, the rules have matured permitting more engineering creativity and sophisticated powertrains. These days maximum power for an fSAE car is specified as 610 cc motorcycle engine; the students display their engineering creativity in the vehicle systems and chassis designs.

The competition is designed to resemble the challenges of new model creation within a major automotive manufacturer. Except that for fSAE the student teams are directed to assume that they have been “hired” to produce a prototype car for evaluation for eventual production. Their intended sales market is the nonprofessional weekend autocross enthusiast. Accordingly, the car they develop and build must have high performance attributes in areas like handling, braking and acceleration but be low in initial cost, yet reliable and easy to maintain. Students must develop not only the car but also the corollary manufacturing and marketing programs. Marketing features, such as esthetics, comfort, use of common parts and recyclability, must be addressed. The manufacturing plan must provide for production of four cars per day with target maximum retail selling price of $25,000 each.

Each phase and aspect is critically evaluated and judged during the course of the three day competition. Over the thirteen years that I've been involved with fSAE, I've done everything from setting cones and bucking hay bales, to working as track flagman, weighing and measuring or operating the tilt-table, to team steward. Let me walk you through a typical fSAE competition.

Unofficially it begins Wednesday when teams arrive in all manner of truck and trailer combinations to sign-in, hopeful of a good pit stall assignment. Thursday is the official start, looking and feeling much like the controlled chaos that it is. From first light, these adrenalin-hyped college students must manage their time in order to accomplish all of the tasks before them. They will have to explain their car in detail, justifying their selection of each component before one panel of judges. They will make a marketing and production presentation before another constructively critical panel. They must successfully get their car through safety and tech-inspections, pass a required braking test, demonstrate that the car is within exhaust noise levels when running at full chat, before being permited to move on to the on-track exercises. Just as in the real-world of engineering, deadlines are sacred.

Friday the teams which successfully accomplished the prerequisites on Thursday will begin on-track exercises. Other teams will still be working their way through the various inspections before being permitted to move along to the on-track acceleration run or the maximum lateral “g” test (more commonly known as the skid pad). Acceleration is a timed wide-open, pedal-to-the-metal 75 meter (246 feet) straight line drag-style run. The skid pad is timed twice, once clockwise and the other counterclockwise, with the laps each way negotiated within the 15.25 meter (50.03 feet) diameter circle, where the driving path is only 3 meters (9.84 feet) wide. Just as in the “real world” there are strategies to consider – coping with the prevailing weather, getting tires properly warmed, being in the proper order in the line so there's some rubber already on the track, watching the lines other drivers are taking – because when the event clock expires at the end of the two-hour window, the opportunity to score expires too.

For more on this article and much more grab a copy of Auto Aficionado Magazine on newsstands nationwide!

At top, Steve Daum, SAE's manager of Collegiate Programs who oversees all Formula SAE competitions, addresses the students.
Copyright © Auto Aficionado. All rights reserved.